Skip to content

Abusive litigation: how to document indications in case files

How to organize indications of abusive litigation and document fraud in case files, with the file, page and excerpt of each finding, and how a dossier helps the legal team decide.

Marlos Carmo

Founder of Tolky

Updated on November 16, 2026

9 min read
Abusive litigation: how to document indications in case files

Share

Anyone who defends companies in mass litigation knows the scene: dozens or hundreds of similar lawsuits, nearly identical petitions, attachments that repeat and a short deadline to respond. Reading everything by hand, page by page, does not always fit the routine.

The risk is twofold. On one side, real indications go unnoticed. On the other, suspicion turns into an unsupported allegation, and the argument weakens. The way out is to organize what you find in a way anyone can verify.

This text is informational content about working method and is not legal advice. Each case depends on the facts, the law and your lawyer's guidance. It refers to Brazilian courts and Brazilian procedure.

Updated in November 2026.

What is abusive litigation?

Abusive litigation is the diverted use of the judicial process, such as mass lawsuits with standardized petitions, irregular documents or claims without basis. The Tolky glossary has the short definition and the most cited signals.

The topic has drawn the attention of the courts. Brazil's National Council of Justice (CNJ) published Recommendation No. 159, of October 23, 2024, on the identification, handling and prevention of abusive litigation, available on the CNJ acts portal (Portuguese). This text does not reproduce or interpret the recommendation: for what it says and how to apply it, consult the official text and your lawyer.

Why document indications instead of just alleging?

Documenting matters because a generic allegation of abuse is easy to rebut, and a finding with verifiable evidence is hard to ignore. The difference is being able to point out where, in which file and on which page the signal is.

Four gains appear when the record is well made:

  • Verification. Anyone on the team can open the indicated page and see the same thing as the person who made the record.
  • Prioritization. With the signals listed, it is clear which cases deserve the most attention.
  • Consistency. The team uses the same criteria in every case, instead of depending on each person's reading.
  • Traceability. If someone asks how a conclusion was reached, the path is recorded.

What is the difference between an indication and proof?

An indication is a signal that deserves attention. Proof is what is brought before the judge and assessed. The dossier organizes indications, the lawyer decides whether they support an argument, and the court decides the merits.

AspectIndicationProof
What it isSignal that draws attention and calls for checkingElement presented and assessed in the case
Who assesses itThe legal teamThe court, as provided by law
How it is recordedFile, page, excerpt and justificationAccording to procedural rules
Risk of excessTreating it as proof and alleging without supportNot presenting what existed
Tool roleFind and organizeNone: the decision is human

That is why Contraprova, Tolky's procedural anti-fraud solution, delivers a documented signal, with a confidence level, and not a conclusion. The decision belongs to your team.

Which document signals usually appear?

The most cited signals are inconsistencies between filings and attachments. Each one must be checked in the context of the case, because none proves abuse on its own. The table below gives examples of signals and what to record.

SignalWhere to lookWhat to record
Power of attorney dated after the initial petitionPower of attorney and petitionDates, file and page of each document
Tax ID or data that differ between documentsPetition, power of attorney and attachmentsBoth values and the pages
Proof of address with signs of image editingProof attachmentsFile, page and the metadata or signal observed
Forgotten template field, such as "[NAME]", in the petitionText of the petitionLiteral excerpt and page
Identical petitions in different casesSeveral casesWhich cases and which excerpts match
Document repeated across casesSeveral casesWhich document and where it appears

The last two signals require comparing cases with each other. That kind of comparison in an automated tool is still "coming soon" in Contraprova. Until then, cross-case comparison is done by the team.

How do you document in five steps?

The method is the same with or without a tool: gather the case file, read with fixed criteria, record with literal evidence, rate confidence and hand it to the lawyer. Five steps organize the work.

Step 1: gather the complete case file

Work with the whole case: petition, power of attorney, attachments and docket entries. A finding only has value when you know which file it came from. Keep the original copy intact and work on the record.

Step 2: define the list of checks before reading

Write down the signals you will look for, like those in the previous table, and use the same list in every case. This avoids the bias of looking only for what you already suspect.

Step 3: record each finding with literal evidence

For each signal, note the file, the page, the exact excerpt and a sentence of justification. Without evidence, the signal should not become an allegation: treat it as a hypothesis to verify.

Step 4: rate the confidence

Distinguish what is objective, such as a later date, from what is interpretive, such as a similar writing style. Mark the confidence of each finding so the lawyer knows where to stand firm.

Step 5: deliver a dossier the lawyer can verify

Gather the findings in a short document, ordered by relevance, with page references. The lawyer decides what to use, how and on what grounds.

What does a well-made dossier look like?

A well-made dossier fits in a few pages and lets the lawyer verify each statement without rereading the case file. It has a predictable structure, always the same, so reading is quick.

  • Case identification. Number, parties and date of analysis.
  • Summary. Two or three paragraphs with the most relevant signals and what still needs checking.
  • List of findings. One item per signal, with file, page, literal excerpt, justification and confidence.
  • Limits. What was not analyzed, such as scanned pages without text, so nobody assumes they were read.
  • Suggested next steps. Checks to run, leaving strategy to the lawyer.

The limits section is the most forgotten and the most important. Saying what was not read protects the team and prevents an absence of findings from being read as an absence of problems. A dossier stating "no indications found in the files with text" is useful and honest information.

If your volume is large, standardize the template and always use the same field names. That way, dossiers from different cases can be compared by whoever reads them and, later, organized by portfolio, by plaintiff or by type of signal, always with human review at the center.

Which mistakes should you avoid?

The most common mistakes are treating an indication as proof, generalizing from one case to all and losing the reference to where the signal was.

  • Alleging without support. Saying there is fraud without pointing to a file and page weakens the argument.
  • Treating similarity as abuse. Similar petitions may have legitimate explanations. Record, check and leave the conclusion to the lawyer.
  • Ignoring context. A differing date may have an explanation. Note it and verify.
  • A record without references. If nobody can find the page, the finding is useless.
  • Too much personal data. Case files contain third-party data. Share the dossier only with those who need it and follow your firm's or company's data protection rules.

Where does Contraprova fit?

Contraprova is the procedural anti-fraud product operated by Tolky: it reads the case files, applies forensic checks and delivers a dossier with each indication, the file, the page, the literal excerpt, the justification and the confidence. It is not payment anti-fraud. See the Anti-fraud solution and the Contraprova product.

What the tool does today: rule checks, such as tax ID, dates and file metadata, run immediately, and the AI reads only the pages with a signal, with a spending cap per analysis. Without evidence, the indication is downgraded. Hidden text meant to manipulate the AI is detected and blocked.

What is coming soon: OCR for scanned pages and checks across cases. Today, file, page and consistency checks work on documents with text. Those who receive scanned files should count on manual reading of those pages until OCR arrives.

Uploaded documents do not train models and stay isolated per customer. Billing is per Process Unit of up to 150 pages, with a free trial of 10 units for 30 days. To assess data protection in your case, talk to the team and to your legal counsel. For identity of people, not documents in case files, Tolky has a different solution, described in liveness, selfie with ID and the LGPD. For other uses of AI in legal and operational routines, see process automation with LLMs. See also security and privacy in AI platforms and AI governance.

Frequently asked questions

Is an indication proof of fraud?

No. An indication is a documented signal, with file, page, excerpt and confidence. The decision on whether and how to use it belongs to the legal team.

No. This text and Contraprova organize information in the case file. Strategy and decisions belong to the lawyer.

Does Contraprova read scanned pages?

Not yet. OCR for scanned pages is coming soon. Today, the checks work on documents with text.

Does Contraprova compare one case with others?

Checks across cases are coming soon. Today, the analysis covers each case on its own.

Do my documents train the AI?

No. Documents stay isolated per customer, and each finding has an audit trail with the check, rule or model used and the cost.

What is CNJ Recommendation 159?

It is an act of Brazil's National Council of Justice, dated October 23, 2024, on identification, handling and prevention of abusive litigation. See the official text and your lawyer for what it means in your case.


Conclusion

Documenting well is what separates a suspicion from a finding the team can verify. Record file, page, excerpt and justification, treat each signal as an indication and leave the decision to the lawyer.

Let's talk? See the Anti-fraud solution, see the glossary term or talk to the team →

Share

Tags

  • abusive litigation
  • how to document indications of abusive litigation
  • document fraud in lawsuits
  • dossier of indications
  • procedural anti-fraud
  • mass litigation defense
  • predatory lawsuits
  • Contraprova

About the author

Marlos Carmo

Founder of Tolky

Marlos Carmo is an AI entrepreneur and founder of Tolky, the conversational-era infrastructure and AI CRM that unifies intelligent service, multi-channel support (such as WhatsApp and voice), live CRM, and operational intelligence in a single ecosystem. He is a finalist for the SXSW Innovation Awards and a member of Francesco's Economy, a global network of young entrepreneurs focused on innovation and social impact. He works connecting Artificial Intelligence and digital transformation in projects for large organizations.

Next step

Want to bring this to your operation?

Tati, Tolky's AI assistant, understands your scenario in a few questions, suggests the best path and connects you with someone from the team, with full context.

Read also